What was the most challenging element of the debate project for you personally? Did you overcome that challenge and if so, how did you do so?
The most challenging element from the debate project for me was finding a topic that had two unbiased sides, and that was written in French. To start, we had to find a good argument, write a introduction, then present it to our partner in order to decide on our topic. While finding a topic wasn’t too difficult, writing a good draft of an introduction was tricky because I didn’t really know which topics would be best to dive into to create a well written argument to present to the class. After, neither my partner nor my ideas were good enough for a topic, so we went back to searching. While Le Monde or Radio Canada are great sources, sadly my partner and I couldn’t find anything on either sites to help us with our argument. After lots of research, we finally found a good article to use, even though it was a bit too long for our liking. Another challenging aspect was creating a convincing argument for our audience and writing it formally. Once we had our official topic, it was to find good evidence and to write it formally. Our last step was to fine-tune our original argument with all of our evidence, but there was a lot of rewriting that needed to be done. For instance, when we were mentioning one topic, a different piece of evidence was used, yet it had no relevance to the subject. After doing our final edits, I believe we didn’t have any other conflicts with the project.
How did this project (as presenter or listener) change your perspectives?
This project changed my perspectives in many ways as both a listener and a presenter. For instance as a listener, I was convinced by the presenters and their arguments, as appose to the opposite argument that the audience was supporting. While the audience knew very little on the subject (other than the article that was read at the start of the debate), the opposing side always seemed more convincing as they did the research to understand their subject best. However as a presenter, my partner and I understood both sides to the argument and wrote down key facts for both of them. This was done to help build our original argument. For example, we turned those key point about the apposing side and turned them into questions to help build our argument even more. If someone in the audience asked a question, we had the answer to it, which demonstrated where we stood with our argument.
What were you most proud of in your project?
In my project, I was most proud of the research that was accomplished as well as the presentation done towards the class. My partner and I both did lots of research to build our argument with facts, research experiments, statistics, graphs, etc. We both found a fair amount of evidence, but it was important to use the pieces that were concise for our argument to help make our point clear. It was a lot of hard work and research that was done during and outside of school as well. In the end, our presentation to the class went well: we provided answers to key words and tried our best to explain the ones we didn’t have written down, we spoke clearly to the class when presenting our discussion, and we tried to answer the questions as best as we could. Overall, the project went well, it could have been better but I am confident that our argument was strong regardless.