Canada’s Post-Cold War Peace Keeping Report Card
Somalia:
Causes | Effects of UN intervention | Canada’s Participation | |||||
– July 1 1960 Somalia gains independence from Britain and Italy
– 1991 Barre government is overthrown by rebels which starts a civil war – No stable government in place for Somalia
|
– UN intervenes to provide aid to those suffering. (Operation Restore Hope)
– UN had withdrawn troops and the civil war continued in 1995 – Issue is still unresolved today |
– In late 1992, the 900 soldiers of the Canadian Airborne Regiment were sent to Somalia on a difficult peacekeeping mission
– The Airborne was an elite commando unit, most ready to fight a war. – On March 4, two Somalis were shot – A 16-year-old, Shidane Arone, was tortured and murdered on the base. – Orders were not consistent. At one time the order was to shoot between the legs between the flip-flops and the hem of the garment. At other times the order was not to shoot. – The new Liberal government’s reaction was to disband the Canadian Airborne Regiment and call a commission of inquiry into the whole affair. – The final report: The commission also said it found serious flaws in the Canadian military justice system. The Canadian Airborne Regiment was unfit for duty in Somalia.
|
|||||
Assessment | |||||||
Was Canadian intervention warranted?
Was the outcome of the conflict successful? How significant was Canada’s role? |
Does not meet expectations
0-4 |
Minimally meets expectations
5-6 |
Meets expectations
7-8 |
Exceeds expectations
9-10 |
|||
Comment (Explanation) | Does not meet expectation
Canada has sent the Canadian airborne regiment to Somalia and arrived at a desperate time. However, two things happened after Canada arrived – two Somalis were shot and a 16-year-old, Shidane Arone, was tortured and murdered with 2 Canadian soldiers participated. Also, Canada played a peacekeeping’s role; Canadian government tried to keep peace. However, the government hesitated whether or not to shoot. This was not only not helpful to Somalia, also caused more awful incident |
||||||
Rwanda:
Causes | Effects of UN intervention | Canada’s Participation | |||||
– Two cultures in Rwanda – Hutu and Tutsi
– Tutsi were fairer skinned and more “European” so colonial Belgium favoured them for government positions, they had better jobs, they had better education – 1962 Belgium grants Rwanda independence – Hutu majority takes over
|
– UN Peacekeepers sent in 1993 during a ceasefire between the Interahamwe (Hutu) and the RPF (Rwandan Patriotic Front – Tutsi refugees)
– UN soldiers pull out after 10 of them are killed – UN does not send in more help because there was no official label of a “Genocide” occurring
|
– Romeo Dallaire who is in charge of the UN peace keeping forces
– Sent daily updates to the UN and Canada about the ethnic cleansing occurring – Wanted Canada and the UN to send more troops to defend the Tutsi
|
|||||
Assessment | |||||||
Was Canadian intervention warranted?
Was the outcome of the conflict successful? How significant was Canada’s role? |
Does not meet expectations
0-4 |
Minimally meets expectations
5-6 |
Meets expectations
7-8 |
Exceeds expectations
9-10 |
|||
Comment (Explanation) | Does not meet expectations
Although, Canada and Rwanda have been closely linked in a remarkable number of ways and many Rwandans have studied and lived in Canada, Canada has not really cared and realized the genocide of Tutsi severity. On the other hand, the Canadian government knew perfectly well what was happening and didn’t want to intervene this event at all |
||||||
Desert Storm:
Causes | Effects of UN intervention | Canada’s Participation | |||||
– Iraq believed Kuwait is part of their land
– Claimed that Kuwait’s oil was really their own – Iraq losing to Iran in the Persian Gulf War (1980-1988) – Iraq invades Kuwait Aug 2, 1990
|
– UN (led by the US) respond by sending troops to Saudi Arabia (about 500,000 troops)
– In Jan 1991, failed talks result in the US bombing Iraq and Iraqi held Kuwait – End of February, cease fire is agreed upon and retreating Iraqis allowed back to Iraq |
– Canada joined the multinational force.
– Canada’s combat role was confined to aerial escort missions and aerial ground support interdiction – Army medical and field engineer support, and naval enforcement of the blockade. – Approximately 4,000 Canadians served in the Gulf War
|
|||||
Assessment | |||||||
Was Canadian intervention warranted?
Was the outcome of the conflict successful? How significant was Canada’s role? |
Does not meet expectations
0-4 |
Minimally meets expectations
5-6 |
Meets expectations
7-8 |
Exceeds expectations
9-10 |
|||
Comment (Explanation) | Meets expectations
Canada has joined the force to defense Kuwait under US and helped Kuwait to retreat Iran. Canadian’s combat role was largely in the air and supported medical stuff and field engineer support. Although, Canada’s participation was not very significant, Canada still helped Kuwait as possible as they could |
||||||
Bosnia:
Causes | Effects of UN intervention | Canada’s Participation | |||||
– After WWII, Yugoslavia is ruled by Josef Broz Tito as a communist state
– Suppressed ethnic or religious expression – Tito dies in 1980 and the country falls apart – As different areas claim independence in the 1990s, Serb-dominated Yugoslav army fights back – Led by Slobodan Milosevic |
– In April 6, 1992, UN had been in Sarajevo but pulled out a majority of their troops for safety as Bosnian Serbs attack Sarajevo
– Left a small group of peacekeepers – Dec 1995 Dayton Peace accords split the country up – Separate governments – Demilitarized zone in between – Central government handles banking and foreign policy for both
|
– Canada, as a NATO member, engaged in the controversial air strikes on the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia
– CANBAT 2 was assigned the protection of 2 hospitals – Soldiers sold cigarettes, coffee, alcohol, fuel, clothing and, in one case, even weaponry on the black market.
|
|||||
Assessment | |||||||
Was Canadian intervention warranted?
Was the outcome of the conflict successful? How significant was Canada’s role? |
Does not meet expectations
0-4 |
Minimally meets expectations
5-6 |
Meets expectations
7-8 |
Exceeds expectations
9-10 |
|||
Comment (Explanation) | Does not meet expectation
Canada has sent soldiers to defense Bosnia and CANBAT 2 was assigned the protection of two hospitals. However, CANBAT 2 didn’t help people who need help in the hospitals. Even though, the awful thing was happened again, “As in Somalia, where Canadian soldiers tortured and killed a local teenage looter”. |
||||||
Good job.